FindGreatLawyers.com is a unique service. We are Illinois attorneys who since 2001 have focused our practice on helping people...

Illinois Lawyer Referrals and Legal Guidance

Archive for October, 2009

“So it’s ok that I almost died?”

Thursday, October 22nd, 2009

We hear that comment once or twice a week.  It is almost always related to someone looking to file an Illinois medical malpractice lawsuit.  Hopefully we can shed some light on how these cases work.

Malpractice cases are time intensive, very expensive and often involve review of tens of thousands of pages of medical records.  To put a case together takes around six months of time and you must have an expert willing to testify that they have reviewed all of the medical records and believe that negligence occurred.

Getting to trial can cost between $50,000 to $150,000 or more.  In Cook County, the most plaintiff friendly county in Illinois, patients win approximately 20% of cases that go to trial.  In some downstate counties they haven’t had a successful med mal case in years.  Put another way, your chances of winning the case are about as good as a pitcher getting a hit in baseball.

Most people that call about a possible malpractice lawsuit had one of two things happen to them:  1. The doctor was incredibly rude and lacked compassion, but didn’t cause any harm; or 2. The doctor was negligent and put the patient in a harmful situation that could have killed them.  They might have made a one hour surgery take four hours or possibly caused someone who should have missed no time from work to miss two months and suffer needlessly during that time.

We can’t help people who have suffered some harm that could have killed them or would have left them permanently injured had another physician not caught things in time or luck not played a role.  It’s not "ok that you almost died" it’s that the system is not set up to compensate people with this problem nor is it set up to punish doctors and hospitals that make these mistakes.  In theory you should be able to file a complaint with the Illinois Department of Professional Regulations when a doctor screws up and they should be able to discipline that physician.  But the reality is that organization is way overworked and hardly ever takes action against the license of a medical professional for mistakes that are made.

Put another way, an Illinois malpractice attorney is not going to spend $100,000.00 of their own money to win a case that if successful is going to be worth $200,000.00.  Especially when you consider all of the time it takes and the likelihood that at trial they will lose.

This is hard for people who have been wronged to understand; but if you take the emotion out of it and look at it as an economic decision it will become clearer why it can be so hard to find an attorney if you don’t have a catastrophic result with good evidence of malpractice.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential.

Five quick Illinois legal tips.

Wednesday, October 21st, 2009

Every Wednesday we present five Illinois legal tips based on questions that we have received from people that contact us.

For the 4th time my DUI case has been handed over to a new public defender one week before my trial dates. Is this legal?  Yes it’s legal and unfortunately that’s one of the risks of going with a Public Defender.  That said, any criminal defendant has a right to demand a trial and you can certainly make them give you a final trial date.

My husband and I both want a divorce, but we were told we have to wait six months.  Is that true?  There is a six month waiting period, but that can be waived if you both want the divorce.

How long do I have to file a wrongful death lawsuit?  No more than two years, but sometimes less if the defendant is a Government entity.

Do I need a will if I have a trust?  What Illinois estate planning attorneys will usually do is create a "pour over will" which basically means that anything not mentioned in the trust will get "poured into" the trust based on what the will says.  So you have a will, but you likely won’t have to go to probate court.

My landscaper took a $5,000.00 deposit on some work and then closed his business.  Why can’t I find anyone to sue him on a contingency basis?  Two reasons.  First while his actions are awful, the amount that a lawyer could recover wouldn’t likely justify working on a contingency.  Second, because his business appears to have gone under, collecting seems like a long shot and certainly a lot of work.  Not the answer anyone wants to hear, but certainly the truth.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential.

 

How the jury can find against you and still walk away with a million dollars.

Tuesday, October 20th, 2009

Can you imagine going through a jury trial over one week for medical malpractice and at the end of the trial the jury says "not liable" and your attorney turns to you and says, "congratulations, you are getting one million dollars."  Does that not make sense to you?

The reason this sometimes happens is that in some cases plaintiffs and defendants will enter in to what are known as "hi-low" agreements.  In a nutshell this means that no matter what happens in the trial the two sides agree that the plaintiff will get a minimum of one amount and a maximum of another amount.  It’s basically a way for each side to hedge their bets and to guarantee that they don’t feel like a loser when the case is over.

It almost always happens in cases where the possible verdict could be in the seven figures if the plaintiff wins and nothing if they lose.  These are usually medical malpractice or catastrophic personal injury lawsuits.

An insurance company does this when they think that they could lose and want to limit their losses.  A plaintiff does this because they know that juries usually find in favor of defendants and by agreeing to this they know that they will in the least end up with something substantial.

So we have seen cases where the plaintiff lost, but still was paid.   And we have seen cases where the plaintiff won many millions of dollars, but had that dollar amount drastically reduced.  So sometimes plaintiffs lose and win.  And sometimes defendants lose and win.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential.

Received an un-solicited text from a business? That is against the law.

Monday, October 19th, 2009

For most cellular phone plans, anytime you receive a text message you are charged a fee.  If a business does this then it violates the TCPA ("Telephone Consumer Protection Act"). TCPA is a Federal Law that provides for damages any time this happens.

The big exception to this rule is if a company already had a pre-existing relationship with you.  For example, if you register your gas bill with your cell number and they send you a text message it is likely permissible.  It also isn’t legal to send a text to someone who has agreed to receive them.  Some companies add this to the fine print of the contracts you have with them.

When you do get an illegal text, you should be able to find an attorney on a contingency basis.  This is because these cases are usually class action lawsuits.  In fact there are some Chicago class action law firms that have a handful of attorneys that mostly focus on "junk text" cases.  These cases are done on a class basis because by themselves they are not worth very much money; but as a group they can be worth a substantial amount.

Again, these laws only apply to commercial texts.  So if your friend or co-worker sends you an unwanted text you can’t sue.  If you are getting harassed by text message you should call the police.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential

Miss a court date in Illinois at your own risk

Saturday, October 17th, 2009

Raise your hand if you want to spend your day in court?  Not us either and we are attorneys.  It’s especially no fun to be in court if you are being sued by someone.

Unfortunately, a lot of people take the approach when they are sued that if they just ignore it then hopefully it will go away.  I’ve had someone who blew off court tell me, "It’s un-constitutional for the Judge to find against me since I wasn’t there to tell my side of the story."

Uhm, no it’s not.  Once you are served with court papers (and possibly if you are just aware that you need to be in court), you are responsible for every appearance in court related to that case.  If you don’t show up and are not represented by an attorney then you lose. You can show up to the first ten court dates, but if you miss the 11th then you lose.

When you lose, the Judge enters in what is called a default judgment against you.  In most cases that means the plaintiff gets whatever they are looking for.  Once a default judgment is entered you have only 30 days to get it reversed – this is called vacating a default judgment.  Once those 30 days passes, unless you can show fraud or some extraordinary circumstance then that judgment can’t be reversed.  Fraud would be something like the plaintiff forging your signature to the Judge.  If they do get a default judgment against you, your bank account can be garnished.

Unfortunately we usually get contacted once someone learns that their tax refund has been taken, money is coming from their paycheck or their bank account has disappeared. 

Moral of the story, don’t blow off court.  If you do, take care of business as soon as possible.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential

Getting divorced in Illinois? Do you have a home court advantage?

Friday, October 16th, 2009

Back when Michael Jordan was leading the Bulls to six championships, even when they were the best team in the league, they always won way more games at home than on the road.  The year that they won a record 72 games and lost only 10, nine of those losses were away from Chicago.  Even when they have been mediocre the number of home wins has always been more than road wins.  Why is that?  It’s because home court advantage matters.

This can be true in the law too.  In most cases you don’t have a choice where the case is going to be heard.  If you get rear-ended in Wheaton, your personal injury lawsuit will almost surely be handled in DuPage County.  It’s different with divorce.

In divorce cases you can file the case in the county where either party resides.  The general rule of thumb is that the first person to file and serve the other party wins this issue.  If you are both living in the same house it’s a non-issue.  But if one of you lives in Chicago and the other in Peoria then it’s a huge issue.  One of you will get to drive down the street to court, the other will be taking the day off work and making a road trip.  And this can happen many times. 

The home court rule also applies when you live in one state and your ex lives in another state or country.  If they have moved to Seattle and you are still here, you are faced with flying to Washington every time you are needed in court.  If the case is contested, especially over kids, wouldn’t it be better for you to not have to travel?  I know I wouldn’t want to.

There is an important exception to this rule for people that live in the suburbs of Cook County.  Most Cook County divorces take place at the Daley Center.  But there are also suburban courts for divorce cases at Skokie, Maywood, Rolling Meadows and Markham.  So if you live in Glenview and file for divorce it can happen at Skokie or the Daley Center.  The person who files for divorce chooses.

But the twist to this is that the person who receives the filing can automatically move the case to the Daley Center (note that it has to be done right away).  Why would you want to do this?  If you have a heated, contested case and your attorney has hired a suburban lawyer, it will make it harder on them to have to come downtown for hearings.  In other words, if your lawyer has an office across the street from the courthouse and your spouse’s attorney has to travel 45 minutes or more every time there is a status hearing, you have the home court advantage.  It also makes it more likely that your attorney is familiar with the Judge.  Again, that’s a home court advantage. 

A contested divorce can be ruthless.  Once the case is final you are usually stuck with the Judge’s decision.  Before it gets to that point you are wise to be like Mike and take advantage of any home court advantage you may have.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential

Lock the door to your workout room if kids are around.

Thursday, October 15th, 2009

Or so says the Illinois Appellate Court.  In a recent decision the Court essentially ruled that if you have a treadmill in your house and kids are over playing, it is your job to supervise them and to make sure that they don’t get hurt.

In a nutshell, the case involved a 10 year old girl who with her friends was playing a racing game on the treadmill.  She slipped and severely messed up her hand with surgery and skin grafts required for her treatment.

She had testified that she had used the treadmill before and used one at home.  Despite that, the Court viewed the case as her using a toy and not being under proper adult supervision.  The Judges reversed the decision of the Chicago Judge who dismissed the case.

Like most accidents in the home, this will surely be covered by homeowner’s insurance and the case is not really about one friend suing another.  That said, the homeowner will likely have to pay a huge deductible and will see their insurance rates go up.

The moral of the story for anyone reading this is that you are responsible to supervise kids in your home.  They lost this case because they didn’t stop the kids from using the treadmill as a toy.  We all know that life doesn’t really work this way and when you are with your adult friends in one room, kids are often in another room being kids.  But premises liability lawsuits in Illinois don’t work the same way as life so if it’s your house and someone gets hurt, you are on the hook.  The only real way to protect yourself is to be a helicopter parent hovering over everything that happens.  Or you can at least lock the door to the room with the treadmill.

Since 2001, findgreatlawyers.com has been the leading resource for Illinois attorney referrals and legal guidance. If you would like our help please contact one of our lawyers via our on-line form or call (800) 517-1614. We are based in Chicago, but help people find attorneys for legal matters throughout Illinois.  All inquiries are free and confidential


FindGreatLawyers.com